
For the last 32 years, Republicans have held all 9 places on the Supreme Court of Texas, but in January 2027, four Democrats will reduce the majority to 5-4. The new Fifteenth Court of Appeals—which has statewide jurisdiction and hears all challenges to rulings by the new (since 2024) Texas Business Court—will switch from 3-0 Republican to 3-0 the other way. And Democrats also gained spots on most of the 14 other Texas Courts of Appeals, which oversee trial courts in both civil and criminal matters.
An item by Texas Lawbook editor Mark Curriden in The Dallas Morning News on Nov. 12, 2026, presented comments on how the results of the Nov. 3 elections may affect the “civil justice system and business courts.”
The article reminded me of a study I’d done almost 20 years ago about a shift that had gone the other way. The first Republican Justice since Reconstruction had joined the previously all-Democrat Supreme Court of Texas in 1978, and the last Democrat Justice had left it in 1998.
A law review had recently published an article about the “influence” of all 50 states’ highest courts between 1940 and 2005–with influence as a proxy for the quality of the courts’ decisions—and I wanted to see how the replacement of Democrats with Republicans had affected the standing of the Texas judiciary among the judiciaries of its sister states. The results surprised me.
As I wrote in the June 2008 issue of Barnett’s Notes on Commercial Litigation:
The Supreme Court of Texas (official site here) wielded by far the most influence during the six years when a balance of Democratic and Republican justices sat on it.
From 1940 until 2005, the Court issued 16 opinions that attracted the full agreement of a non-Texas high court on a point of law at least three times. The relevant decisions line up thus:
1940 — 1
1970 — 1
1984 — 2
1985 — 1
1993 — 1
1994 — 3
1995 — 3
1996 — 1
1997 — 1
1998 — 1
2001 — 1
As you can see, during the six years from 1993 through 1998, the justices rendered 10 of the 16 decisions that won three “followeds” in the 65 years between 1940 and 2005. That comes to 62.5 percent in less than 10 percent of the survey period.
Dems/Repubs. What made one six-year period so remarkable? Let’s add the number of Democrats/Republicans on the Court in each of those years:
1940 — 1 9/0
1970 — 1 9/0
1984 — 2 9/0
1985 — 1 9/0
1993 — 1 5/4
1994 — 3 5/4
1995 — 3 4/5
1996 — 1 3/6
1997 — 1 3/6
1998 — 1 3/6
2001 — 1 0/9
Hmmm. In every one of the years from 1993 through 1998, the Court’s composition included a substantial number of justices from each of the major political parties. And the Court’s two most prolific years, 1994 and 1995, happened just at the time of greatest uncertainty about which party would hold a majority.
I hope the new 5-4 Republican-Democrat balance on the Court has a like effect.


