- “You’d think [the new Texas Business Court] would want to resolve this [dispute over its jurisdiction to handle old District Court cases] quickly because the whole idea is you don’t
antitrust
Commercial Roundup – April 16, 2024
- Multiple terms in speech-recognition patent deserved broader construction.
- Allowing any discovery on arbitrability amounts to denial of stay and authorizes immediate appeal.
- Internet service provider’s failure to boot subscribers it knew often pirated music online made
Commercial Roundup – January 10, 2024
- Promise to charge “competitive” price for power didn’t require price lower than default utility charged.
- Hot off the Antitrust Division and FTC presses.
- Contract naming Chinese parent firm as consignee of cattle feed did not make parent a party to contract its
“You can’t equate a benefit to some consumers to a pro-competitive effect.”
U.S. Circuit Judge Jennifer Sung made the comment December 6 during oral argument in the Federal Trade Commission’s ongoing effort to block Microsoft’s $69 billion purchase of Activision Blizzard, the biggest U.S. maker of video games. (Hat tip to Josh Sisco at Politico Pro.) The FTC claimed that the merger threatened to substantially reduce competition…
Alaska-Hawaiian Merger Might Crash into the 2023 Draft Merger Guidelines

The $1.9 billion deal Alaska Airlines signed with Hawaiian Airlines on December 3 would enable the competitors to collaborate on the 12 routes they both fly between the Aloha State and cities on the U.S. West Coast–a small part of their overall networks. Does that mean the Antitrust Division will challenge the deal?
Probably.
I…
Commercial Roundup – November 15, 2023
- Expert witness
What $26.3 Billion Bought Google, and the Cost of Secrecy

Last Friday, October 27, U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta overruled an objection by Google’s trial counsel to a question about how much the online search and ad giant pays Apple and other browser providers for making Google’s search engine the default. The lawyer claimed that making the dollar amount public would hurt Google’s negotiating position…
Commercial Roundup – August 23, 2023

This late-summer edition of Commercial Roundup features a notable ruling on personal jurisdiction, a pair of False Claims Act decisions, a couple of opinions tossing class certification orders, a 2-1 split in a securities fraud case (the dissent has the better end of it), a rare victory for plaintiffs in an action for unlawful maintenance…
Big Boost in Antitrust Funding Won’t Happen in 2023

As I mentioned last month in Antitrust Enforcers Must Have More Funding, the Antitrust Division in the Department of Justice and the Federal Trade Commission need a boost of $340 million from current funding just to return them (in constant dollars) to 1979…
Commercial Roundup – July 26, 2023
- Antitrust